UPSC Mains — Previous Year Question
Question
Do you think digital technology promotes social empowerment? Explain with examples.
Model Answer
Digital technology has shifted empowerment from merely access to services towards access to information, opportunities and voice; however, its benefits depend on digital access, literacy and inclusion.
Digital Technology as an Enabler of Social Empowerment
- 1. Financial Autonomy: Digital payments and banking enhance economic agency among women, migrants and informal workers; JAM-UPI enables low-cost transactions without dependence on intermediaries.
- 2. Welfare Empowerment: DBT and Aadhaar-enabled delivery reduce dependence on middlemen and improve access to entitlements for poor, elderly, and vulnerable beneficiaries.
- 3. Educational Empowerment: Digital learning expands opportunities for rural, tribal, and disadvantaged students; DIKSHA and PM e-VIDYA provide learning resources beyond geographical constraints.
- 4. Healthcare Inclusion: Telemedicine improves access for remote communities and persons with mobility constraints; e-Sanjeevani enables remote doctor consultations, reducing distance barriers.
- 5. Women’s Agency: Digital literacy and connectivity strengthen women’s voice, livelihood choices and market access; the Sanchar Shakti initiative supported rural women and SHG members in using ICT for livelihood skills.
- 6. Tribal & Marginalised Livelihoods: Digital platforms connect tribal artisans directly to wider markets; platforms like TRIFED’s Tribes India facilitate digital marketing of tribal products.
- 7. Voice & Civic Participation: Portals like MyGov and CPGRAMS enable marginalized groups to express concerns and access grievance redressal channels directly.
- 8. Inclusion & Identity: Accessible digital services improve social participation for persons with disabilities, eliminating physical barriers to public information.
Digital Technology as a Source of New Exclusion
- 1. Access & Infrastructure Divide: Unequal connectivity and device access exclude remote communities; only 14.9% of rural households have internet access compared with 42% of urban households.
- 2. Gendered Digital Divide: Social norms constrain women’s access; NFHS-6 found only 64% of women aged 15–49 had ever used the internet, compared with 80% of men.
- 3. Technology-Induced Welfare Exclusion: Authentication and connectivity failures prevent genuine beneficiaries from accessing entitlements; a field study in Ranchi, Jharkhand documented biometric failures disrupting PDS ration distribution.
- 4. Cybersecurity Vulnerability: Greater digital dependence exposes citizens to fraud and online exploitation; NCRB recorded 86,420 cybercrime cases in 2023, of which 59,526 (68.9%) involved financial fraud.
- 5. Algorithmic & Accessibility Exclusion: Biased datasets and non-vernacular interfaces exclude low-literacy users and persons with disabilities.
Policy Approaches for Digital Inclusion in India
- Bridge Digital Divide (Access): Expand BharatNet for last-mile rural broadband connectivity.
- Build Digital Literacy (Skills): Scale PMGDISHA for vulnerable groups.
- Promote Inclusive Design (Equity): Deploy Bhashini and Sugamya Bharat for language translation and disability inclusion.
- Ensure Assisted Access (Support): Strengthen Common Service Centres (CSCs) for digitally excluded citizens.
- Protect Digital Rights (Trust): Implement the Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act, 2023 strictly alongside cybersecurity enforcement.
As Amartya Sen’s capability approach suggests, development is about expanding substantive freedoms; digital technology can fulfil this role only when access, capability, and inclusion accompany connectivity.