UPSC Mains — Previous Year Question
Question
“Those who in trouble untroubled are, Will trouble trouble itself.” – Thiruvalluvar
Model Answer
In this couplet from the Tirukkural, the sage-poet Thiruvalluvar reflects on the ethical virtue of equanimity and inner fortitude. The core message is that external difficulties do not determine an outcome on their own; an individual who maintains moral composure, emotional control, and steady judgment can overcome adversity effectively.
Ethical Dimensions of Composure in Adversity
- Emotional Intelligence & Executive Self-Regulation: High emotional intelligence enables public servants to remain objective during crises rather than reacting out of panic, preserving rational decision-making (e.g., healthcare leadership maintaining calm coordination during pandemic surges).
- The Virtue of Fortitude (Aristotelian Ethics): Aristotle identified fortitude (moral courage) as the golden mean between rashness and cowardice, enabling an administrator to face political, social, and physical risks while upholding public duty.
- Administrative Exemplar: E. Sreedharan (“Metro Man”) managed complex logistical, technical, and political hurdles while maintaining project timelines, guided by professional focus.
- Stoic Detachment and Resilience: Stoic philosophy emphasizes that while external crises cannot always be prevented, one’s internal response remains entirely within one’s control.
- Administrative Exemplar: T.N. Seshan implemented major electoral reforms as Chief Election Commissioner despite facing significant political opposition, adhering strictly to constitutional rules.
- Resourceful Problem-Solving Under Constraints: Remaining calm under pressure allows leaders to find innovative community-led solutions during administrative logjams.
- Administrative Exemplar: Armstrong Pame (IAS) mobilized community support to construct the 100-km “People’s Road” in Manipur when formal state funds were delayed.
- The Gandhian Principle of Satyagraha: Peaceful resolve and inner discipline can withstand severe opposition without resorting to bitterness or violence, as demonstrated during the Salt March.
- Inspiring Collective Trust: A composed administrative leader reassures frontline workers and the public during disasters, preventing rumors and disorganized responses (e.g., district disaster managers maintaining calm communication during flood relief operations).
- Commitment to Probity: Upholding personal integrity during scrutiny requires fortitude to resist intimidation while maintaining transparency (e.g., civil servants reporting irregularities despite frequent transfers).
Thiruvalluvar’s insight demonstrates that fortitude, equanimity, and emotional intelligence are essential virtues in public life. Composure under pressure enables civil servants to transform administrative challenges into opportunities for ethical public service.