UPSC Mains — Previous Year Question
Question
Does urbanisation lead to more segregation and/or marginalisation of the poor in Indian metropolises?
Model Answer
While classical urban sociological theory posits that modern cities serve as democratic “melting pots” that dissolve traditional hierarchies, urbanization in contemporary Indian metropolises (e.g., Mumbai, Delhi, Bengaluru) presents a dual reality: it offers economic mobility while producing spatial segregation and socioeconomic marginalization of low-income populations.
How Urbanisation Contributes to Segregation of the Poor
- 1. Spatial and Residential Dualism:
- Indian metropolitan expansion is characterized by sharp residential contrasts: high-income gated communities and luxury high-rises develop alongside crowded informal settlements and slums lacking basic services.
- According to census data, over 65 million citizens reside in urban slums, with large cities accommodating a substantial share of their residents in informal housing.
- 2. Market-Driven Gentrification and Peripheral Resettlement:
- High land values and urban redevelopment projects often push working-class populations to the city periphery, distant from employment centers and transit corridors, raising commuting costs.
- 3. Socio-Religious and Caste Clustering:
- Traditional social identities can influence urban real estate access. Rental market discrimination often concentrates minority and Dalit migrants into specific neighborhood clusters or “ghettos”.
- 4. Informal Labor Segmentations:
- Migrants without formal technical credentials are absorbed largely into low-wage informal work (construction labor, domestic work, street vending), limiting career progression and social security access.
How Urbanisation Contributes to Marginalisation
- Deficits in Basic Municipal Amenities: Informal settlements often experience irregular access to piped municipal water, sanitation networks, and waste collection, creating localized public health challenges.
- Tenure Insecurity and Eviction Risks: Absence of formal property titles leaves informal settlements vulnerable to demolition and eviction without adequate compensation or rehabilitation.
- Political and Civic Disenfranchisement: Circular and seasonal migrant workers often lack local voter registration and identity proofs, reducing their voice in municipal policymaking.
The Counter-Perspective: Cities as Spaces of Opportunity
- Social Anonymity from Rural Caste Surveillance: Large cities provide anonymity from village caste hierarchies, allowing marginalized individuals to take up diverse occupations without traditional social restrictions.
- Economic Mobility and Remittance Generation: Urban informal and gig sectors provide higher cash wages than rural agricultural work, enabling families to finance education and healthcare in their home districts.
Policy Interventions for Inclusive Urban Spaces
- In-situ slum upgrading and affordable rental housing under Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (Urban).
- Expanding social security protections for urban informal workers (modeled on the Rajasthan Platform Based Gig Workers Act, 2023).
- Upgrading affordable public transport to ensure peripheral low-income communities remain connected to metropolitan job markets.
Urbanization carries the potential for social mobility, but without equitable urban planning, market-led growth can exacerbate spatial divisions. Building inclusive cities requires integrating informal communities into formal housing, basic utilities, and participatory municipal governance.