UPSC Mains — Previous Year Question
Question
Why did human development fail to keep pace with economic development in India?
Model Answer
Since the 1991 economic reforms, India has emerged as one of the fastest-growing major economies, projected to become the third-largest economy globally. However, this GDP expansion has not translated proportionally into human development indicators: India ranked 132nd out of 191 nations in the 2021/22 UNDP Human Development Index (HDI), illustrating a gap between economic growth and social progress.
Reasons Human Development Failed to Keep Pace with Economic Development
- 1. Low Public Investment in Social Infrastructure:
- Public spending on healthcare has historically hovered around 1.3–1.4% of GDP (against the 2.5% target set by the National Health Policy 2017), while education expenditure has remained around 3% of GDP (below the 6% target of NEP 2020).
- 2. Structural Growth Skew (Capital-Intensive Service Model):
- India transitioned directly from agriculture to a skill-intensive services sector (IT, finance) without developing a broad-based, labor-intensive manufacturing sector. Consequently, economic expansion generated limited formal employment, leaving roughly 45% of the workforce in low-productivity agriculture.
- 3. Persistent Quality Gaps in Public Education:
- While school enrollment rates have improved under the Right to Education Act, learning assessments (such as ASER surveys) indicate persistent deficits in basic literacy and numeracy among rural primary students.
- 4. Healthcare Gaps and Out-of-Pocket Expenditure (OOPE):
- High reliance on private healthcare results in significant out-of-pocket medical expenses, which can push vulnerable households into poverty following health emergencies. Rural Community Health Centres also face specialist staffing shortages.
- 5. Deep-Rooted Sociocultural Inequalities:
- Structural caste stratification, gender discrimination, and regional disparities have limited the distribution of economic benefits, leaving Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, and women with lower socioeconomic indicators.
- 6. High Burden of Child Malnutrition:
- Despite sustained economic growth, NFHS-5 data indicates that roughly 35.5% of children under five are stunted and 32.1% are underweight, impacting long-term cognitive potential and adult workforce productivity.
- 7. The “Resource Curse” and Regional Asymmetries:
- Mineral-rich central and eastern states have struggled to convert industrial resource extraction into improved human development outcomes for local populations.
Measures Required to Fast-Track Human Development
- Increase government social sector outlays to benchmark targets (2.5% of GDP for health, 6% for education).
- Promote labor-intensive manufacturing (textiles, electronics, leather) through targeted industrial policy to absorb rural labor into formal wage employment.
- Focus on foundational learning and primary healthcare networks through Ayushman Arogya Mandirs and NIPUN Bharat.
As Amartya Sen argues, economic growth is a means to expand human capabilities and freedoms rather than an end in itself. Aligning economic growth with human development is essential to achieve sustainable, inclusive progress.