UPSC Mains — Previous Year Question
Question
Compare and Contrast the British and Indian approaches to Parliamentary Sovereignty.
Model Answer
While both India and the United Kingdom follow the Westminster model of parliamentary democracy, they adopt distinct approaches to Parliamentary Sovereignty. The UK system is founded on the doctrine of absolute parliamentary supremacy, whereas India operates under the doctrine of Constitutional Sovereignty with institutional checks and balances.
Comparative Matrix: British vs. Indian Approaches
| Dimension | British Approach | Indian Approach |
|---|---|---|
| Constitutional Basis | Unwritten/uncodified constitution based on statutes, conventions, and common law precedents. | Written, codified Constitution serving as the supreme law of the land. |
| Sovereign Authority | Parliament is sovereign; A.V. Dicey noted it can make or unmake any law without legal challenge. | The Constitution is sovereign; Parliament derives its powers from and operates within constitutional limits. |
| Scope of Judicial Review | Limited; British courts cannot strike down primary parliamentary legislation as unconstitutional. | Robust judicial review under Articles 13, 32, and 226; courts can invalidate unconstitutional laws. |
| Amendment Constraints | Flexible; amendments can be passed by a simple majority without special procedures. | Structured under Article 368; requires special majorities and, in federal matters, state ratifications. |
| Basic Structure Limit | No equivalent doctrine; Parliament can alter constitutional arrangements at will. | Subject to the Basic Structure Doctrine (Kesavananda Bharati, 1973); essential features cannot be amended. |
| State Structure | Unitary state; authority emanates from Westminster, which can revoke devolved powers. | Federal system with constitutional division of powers between Centre and States (Seventh Schedule). |
| Fundamental Rights | Rights protected through common law and the Human Rights Act 1998, which Parliament can amend. | Guaranteed, entrenched Fundamental Rights under Part III that bind parliamentary enactments. |
While the British system prioritizes parliamentary supremacy, the Indian Constitution synthesizes parliamentary authority with judicial review, anchoring governance in constitutional morality.