Circular
Learnings
UPSC CSE Preparation
UPSC Mains — Previous Year Question
2023 GS2 Social Justice 15 Marks
Question
“Development and welfare schemes for the vulnerable, by its nature, are discriminatory in approach.” Do you agree? Give reasons for your answer.
Model Answer

Welfare programs designed specifically for disadvantaged cohorts—such as Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, women, children, persons with disabilities, and religious minorities—frequently draw scrutiny regarding whether targeting constitutes unfair administrative discrimination. However, in constitutional jurisprudence, targeted welfare represents positive discrimination (substantive equality) intended to correct historical disadvantages, though implementation challenges can generate unintended exclusionary side-effects.

1. Why Targeted Schemes Are Justified: Substantive Equality (Affirmative Action)

  • Distributive Justice and Equity over Formal Equality:
    • Treating unequals equally perpetuates underlying inequality. Aristotelian justice and John Rawls’ Difference Principle support targeted state intervention to improve the conditions of the least advantaged.
  • Constitutional Mandate:
    • The Indian Constitution explicitly authorizes targeted welfare under Articles 15(3), 15(4), 16(4), and 46, directing the State to advance social justice through specialized educational, financial, and credit measures.
  • Resource Optimization in a Developing Economy:
    • Given fiscal constraints, targeting resources toward acute deprivation (e.g., micronutrient interventions for tribal children, subsidized credit under Stand-Up India for SC/ST and female entrepreneurs) yields higher developmental impact than untargeted subsidies.
  • Rectifying Historical Structural Deprivation:
    • Targeted programs provide compensatory support to help communities overcome generational socio-economic exclusion.

2. Why Targeted Welfare Can Be Perceived as Discriminatory / Problematic

  • Exclusion Errors and Borderline Vulnerabilities:
    • Rigid social category or income criteria can exclude impoverished households belonging to non-targeted demographics (e.g., poor individuals from general categories), generating feelings of neglect.
  • Social Stigmatization and Othering:
    • Explicitly categorizing beneficiaries based on caste or social vulnerability can inadvertently reinforce group labels and social divisions within communities.
  • Top-Down Design Without Participatory Input:
    • Programs designed without community consultation can fail to address local needs or create administrative barriers to access.
  • Administrative Leakages and Inaccuracies:
    • Outdated Below Poverty Line (BPL) surveys or incomplete socio-economic registries can lead to targeting inaccuracies where affluent individuals claim benefits while eligible recipients are left out.

The Way Forward

  • Combine targeted affirmative programs with universal foundational services (e.g., quality public schooling, primary healthcare, clean drinking water) available to all citizens.
  • Adopt dynamic, data-driven beneficiary targeting (using SECC registries, Aadhaar de-duplication, and open social audits) to minimize exclusion errors.

Targeted welfare programs represent positive affirmative action aimed at advancing constitutional equality. Ensuring objective targeting and transparent administration helps deliver assistance to those in need without generating social friction.

Keep Exploring

More PYQs from Circular Learnings