Circular
Learnings
UPSC CSE Preparation
UPSC Mains — Previous Year Question
2023 GS2 Polity & Constitution 10 Marks
Question
Discuss the role of Presiding Officers of state legislatures in maintaining order and impartiality in conducting legislative work and in facilitating best democratic practices.
Model Answer

Under Article 178 of the Constitution, the Speaker and Deputy Speaker serve as the Presiding Officers of State Legislative Assemblies, responsible for maintaining procedural order, ensuring impartiality, and upholding democratic traditions within the House.

Role in Maintaining Order and Conducting Legislative Work

  • Presiding Over Assembly Sittings: Regulates proceedings, enforces legislative rules of procedure, admits motions, and decides on points of order.
  • Ensuring Decorum and Discipline: Exercises disciplinary authority to name or suspend legislators engaging in unparliamentary language, disruptions, or disorderly conduct to maintain legislative dignity.
  • Allocating Assembly Time: Balances government business with opposition debates, distributing speaking time to ensure diverse political viewpoints are heard.
  • Casting Vote in Ties: Exercises a casting vote under Article 189(1) only in the event of an equality of votes, traditionally used to maintain the status quo rather than express partisan preference.
  • Committee Oversight: Appoints chairpersons and members to House committees, overseeing financial and departmental legislative scrutiny.

Role in Facilitating Best Democratic Practices

  • Impartial Adjudication: Acts as an objective umpire between treasury and opposition benches, ensuring the minority voice is heard while the majority’s legislative business proceeds.
  • Adjudication Under the Anti-Defection Law (Tenth Schedule): Acts as a constitutional tribunal under the Tenth Schedule to decide petitions regarding disqualification of defecting members.
  • Consensus Building: Convenes regular Business Advisory Committee meetings and all-party discussions to resolve floor logjams and build procedural consensus.

Emerging Concerns and Institutional Challenges

  • Perceived Partisanship: Speakers often remain active political party members, leading to allegations of bias in floor management or time allocations.
  • Delays in Deciding Defection Petitions: In several states, delayed adjudications on Tenth Schedule disqualifications have attracted judicial scrutiny (e.g., Keisham Meghachandra Singh case).
  • Bypassing Scrutiny: Certification of contentious bills as Money Bills to bypass upper chamber review can lead to procedural controversies.

Way Forward

  • Adopt the British convention where the Speaker formally resigns from party affiliation upon election to ensure institutional neutrality.
  • Consider establishing an independent permanent tribunal headed by a retired judge to adjudicate defection petitions, as recommended by the Supreme Court and the NCRWC.

Maintaining the independence of Presiding Officers is essential to preserving the credibility and deliberative character of state legislatures.

Keep Exploring

More PYQs from Circular Learnings