UPSC Mains — Previous Year Question
Question
Discuss the impact of post-liberal economy on ethnic identity and communalism.
Model Answer
The adoption of Liberalisation, Privatisation, and Globalisation (LPG) reforms in 1991 transformed India’s developmental model from state-directed planning to a market-oriented economy. This transformation significantly influenced sociological formations, altering the expressions of ethnic identity and the dynamics of communalism.
Impact of Post-Liberal Economy on Ethnic Identity
1. Positive Transformations
- Global Exposure and Indigenous Revitalization: Global market connectivity and e-commerce platforms have allowed tribal and ethnic craftspeople to market traditional art, textiles, and organic produce internationally (e.g., GI-tagged crafts, TRIFED portals), providing sustainable incomes.
- Ethnic Tourism and Cultural Assertions: The expansion of ecotourism in regions like the Northeast has elevated ethnic traditions into valued cultural capital, encouraging communities to document and preserve their heritage.
- Emergence of Transnational Diasporic Networks: Outbound migration and global capital flows have helped regional linguistic and ethnic groups establish international community networks.
2. Tensions and Vulnerabilities
- Resource Extraction and Land Alienation: Expanding private investments in mining, dam construction, and commercial corridors have contributed to the displacement of forest-dwelling tribal communities in central and eastern India, sparking ethnic land-defense movements.
- Fear of Cultural Assimilation: Market consumerism and mass entertainment can challenge local languages and customs, prompting protective ethnic mobilization to safeguard customary practices.
- Intra-Regional Resource Competition: Uneven regional development has exacerbated inter-ethnic competition over scarce public jobs and natural resources in border areas (e.g., localized ethnic frictions in parts of the Northeast).
Impact of Post-Liberal Economy on Communalism
1. Interdependence Mitigating Communal Divisions
- Commercial Integration: Integrated urban markets and corporate business operations foster commercial interdependence across religious groups, where trade relationships and financial linkages disincentivize communal disruptions.
- Shared Cosmopolitan Workplaces: Modern private service sectors (IT, aviation, retail) operate on professional norms that bring diverse communities together in shared workspaces.
2. Economic Drivers Exacerbating Communalism
- Unequal Wealth Distribution & Relative Deprivation: Market reforms have contributed to widening economic inequality. Reports like the Sachar Committee (2006) highlighted disparities in access to formal credit, education, and public sector employment among certain minority segments, fueling feelings of marginalization.
- Competition in the Informal Economy: Deregulation and urban migration create competition in the informal trading sector, which can be mobilized along religious lines during economic downturns.
- Digital Amplification of Communal Polarization: Low-cost mobile broadband and algorithmic social media feeds have facilitated the rapid circulation of unverified sectarian content, increasing the volatility of communal tensions.
- Ghettoization in Urban Centers: In several industrial cities, real estate segmentation and communal anxieties have led to residential clustering along religious lines, reducing cross-community interaction.
The post-liberal economy has fostered commercial interdependence while generating regional disparities and resource competition. Managing these pressures requires pairing market-led growth with equitable welfare distribution and constitutional secularism.