UPSC Mains — Previous Year Question
Question
Do you think marriage as a sacrament is losing its value in modern India?
Model Answer
In classical Indian sociology, Hindu marriage was conceived as a sacrament (Sanskara)—an indissoluble spiritual union intended for performing religious and familial duties (Dharma, Praja, Rati)—rather than a mere civil contract. In contemporary India, socioeconomic modernization, female empowerment, and legal shifts have altered the nature of this institution, though traditional cultural values persist.
Arguments That Marriage as a Sacrament is Diluting (Contractual Transition)
- Growing Individualism & Personal Autonomy: Urbanization, higher education, and personal career ambitions have shifted marriage from a family-arranged alliance toward individual choice, where personal compatibility takes priority over ritual indissolubility.
- Rise of Divorce and Legal Separation: Historically rare, divorce rates in urban centers have risen as marital distress is increasingly addressed through civil dissolution under personal law frameworks, moving away from lifelong sacrifice.
- Alternative Domestic Partnerships: Growing social and judicial acceptance of live-in relationships, prenuptial agreements, and single-parent adoptions illustrates changing views on marriage as a mandatory prerequisite for companionship or family life.
- Secularization of Marital Ceremonies: For many urban professionals, weddings have partially shifted from religious rites toward lifestyle events, personal celebration, and conspicuous consumption.
- Judicial Protections for Individual Rights: Judicial decisions recognizing bodily autonomy and privacy under Article 21 place personal choice above traditional marital expectations.
Arguments That the Sacramental Value Endures (Continuity Amid Change)
- Enduring Religious and Social Sanctity: For the majority of rural and semi-urban households, marriages remain deeply embedded in religious rituals (Saptapadi, Kanyadaan, Nikah, Anand Karaj), retaining high spiritual significance.
- Continued Prevalence of Arranged Marriages: Family-assisted and community-mediated alliances remain the dominant form of marriage in India, preserving familial networks and social continuity.
- Low Baseline Divorce Rate: Despite localized increases in urban centers, India’s overall divorce rate remains among the lowest globally (around 1%), reflecting the durable social expectation of marital continuity.
- Centrality of the Family Unit: Marriage continues to be viewed as a foundational pillar for social security, child-rearing, and intergenerational caregiving.
Marriage in India is not abandoning its traditional values; rather, it is accommodating individual agency, gender equality, and democratic rights, evolving from an indissoluble sacrament toward an institution built on mutual respect and companionship.