UPSC Mains — Previous Year Question
Question
Why do large cities tend to attract more migrants than smaller towns? Discuss in the light of conditions in developing countries.
Model Answer
According to UN-Habitat projections, over 68% of the global population will reside in urban areas by 2050. In developing countries, internal rural-urban migration flows disproportionately toward Tier-I megacities (e.g., Mumbai, Delhi, Lagos, São Paulo) rather than smaller intermediate towns, reflecting regional imbalances in industrial investment and infrastructure.
Reasons Large Cities Attract More Migrants (Centripetal Pull Factors)
- Diverse Labor Markets: Megacities offer broad labor absorption across corporate services, construction, manufacturing, and informal gig platforms. Migrants find lower search costs and varied income streams compared to smaller towns.
- Specialized Healthcare and Education: Large cities host premier tertiary healthcare facilities and universities (e.g., AIIMS, Delhi University), attracting students and families seeking social mobility.
- Concentration of Public and Private Capital: Industrial investments, technological parks, and multinational offices concentrate in major urban corridors (e.g., Bengaluru, Hyderabad), generating direct and indirect employment multipliers.
- Pre-Existing Kinship and Migrant Networks: Established community networks provide newcomers with informal credit, temporary accommodation, and job referrals, lowering the transition risks of migration.
- Superior Physical and Civic Infrastructure: Large urban centers receive greater municipal financing for suburban rail lines, metro networks, water supply, and commercial centers.
- Social Anonymity: For historically marginalized groups (e.g., Dalits), large urban spaces provide anonymity from traditional rural caste hierarchies, offering greater personal dignity and economic mobility.
Why Smaller Towns Struggle to Retain or Attract Migrants (Push Factors)
- Monolithic and Stagnant Economies: Secondary towns often depend on agricultural markets or single agro-processing sectors, offering limited formal employment opportunities for educated youth.
- Deficits in Basic Public Infrastructure: Smaller municipal bodies face severe revenue constraints, resulting in erratic electricity, poor road connectivity, and inadequate drainage networks.
- Shortages in Higher Education & Healthcare: Tier-III towns lack multi-specialty hospitals and professional engineering/medical colleges, driving families toward primary metropolitan hubs.
- Limited Private Investment: Logistical bottlenecks and smaller consumer bases lead corporate capital to bypass smaller towns in favor of developed metropolitan periphery zones.
To reduce pressure on congested megacities, developing economies must promote balanced regional development through programs like the Smart Cities Mission and PURA, upgrading infrastructure and job opportunities in secondary and tertiary towns.